Proteinmaxxing Backfired: One Man’s Health Scare

During a recent checkup, my doctor reviewed my latest blood tests and paused. “You have high uric acid,” he said. “It’s a precursor to gout.” I was stunned. I exercised often, played football a couple of times a week, and followed a healthy diet, yet here I was, looking at a potential gout diagnosis. The cause, it turned out, was my protein habit.

I was in my mid thirties with roughly 15 percent body fat, not exactly the typical gout profile. Men are four times more likely than women to develop gout, but it usually affects those with obesity, high blood pressure, or diabetes, and most often in their sixties. My doctor looked at me and asked, “Do you eat a lot of protein?” I told him I was eating about 200 grams per day. He explained that consuming that much protein can raise uric acid levels and lead to gout in otherwise fit people. Fortunately, I was able to avoid gout, but the problem is widespread.

Based on data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 3.9 percent of U.S. adults, or 9.2 million people, had gout in 2016, and 5.9 million of those cases were men. Experts believe our obsession with proteinmaxxing is partly to blame, along with an increase in gut issues. “This is a real thing,” says Dr. Spencer Kroll, an internal medicine specialist. “As we’re seeing this explosion of protein availability and encouragement, we’re running into some problems.”

Gout is a type of arthritis caused when uric acid buildup forms sodium urate crystals in the joints. It is generally considered the most painful form of arthritis. “Classically, it occurs in the toes,” says Dr. Kroll. “But gout can appear anywhere in your body, and the pain can be severe.” Many protein rich foods, including red meat and some seafood, contain purines, which are converted to uric acid, creating the link between protein and gout.

Dietician Kylie King has noticed the trend. “I remember distinctly when protein recommendations started to get really high, about five years ago,” she says. “I was suddenly having a lot of clients come in with these protein recommendations that were given to them by their personal trainers or what they were seeing online.” The trend has only intensified, culminating in proteinmaxxing, a well intentioned but misguided strategy to maximize protein at every turn. Dr. Kroll describes a recent patient who came to him after eating high amounts of protein to bulk up. “He came into my office, hobbling, because he couldn’t walk. It turned out his uric acid level was extremely high. The fix for him, in addition to giving him some acute medication for the pain, was to reduce the amount of protein, and specifically meat, that he was taking in.”

Excessive protein also raises the risk of kidney stones. Uric acid stones, one of the common types, result from a buildup of uric acid. King says it usually comes from high protein, especially animal protein, combined with low hydration. A second type, calcium oxalate stones, makes up about 80 percent of all kidney stones. These are not directly caused by protein but by low calcium levels. “Sometimes, when someone switches to a predominantly protein-based diet, they may develop a deficiency of calcium as a result,” Dr. Kroll says. “They may be isolating the protein from dairy products, as in the case of whey, which doesn’t contain a lot of calcium. So those people are at increased risk for calcium stones.” King notes that kidney stones are incredibly painful, but protein alone isn’t the only factor. She recommends keeping calcium rich foods like dairy and leafy greens in your diet and checking family history, which roughly doubles the risk.

Bad breath is another side effect of eating too much protein. “The issue of bad breath is real,” King says. “People often assume it’s a hydration issue, when it’s actually metabolic.” The body breaks down protein into nitrogen and then ammonia, and excess protein means more ammonia on the breath. If high protein is paired with very low carbs, the body also produces acetone as a result of ketosis, which can smell like nail polish remover. “Depending on whether someone is consuming an excessively high amount of protein or high protein and low carb, you can get two different halitosis outcomes,” King says. Mints and gum, in these cases, are like Band-Aids for a bullet wound.

The good news is that most people don’t need as much protein as they think. “Most people don’t need anywhere near the amount of protein they’re being sold,” King says. “No more than 40 percent of your caloric intake should come from protein,” adds Dr. Kroll. “There’s really no reason for a person to pack in more than 200 grams of protein per day. It’s like taking in too many vitamins. It’s just going into the toilet.” Staying hydrated is also vital, as water helps excrete uric acid and supports gut health. “Heavy protein intake without adequate fiber and water disrupts gut function quickly,” King says. “Digestive issues like constipation, bloating, and GI discomfort are among the most common downsides I see.”

Not all protein is the same. Purines are present in almost every protein source, but red meat and seafood are the ones that truly increase uric acid. “There are some plants and vegetable products that have purines in them, but, interestingly, it seems from the data that their purines don’t cause the gout symptoms,” Dr. Kroll says. Adding plant based proteins can help ensure you get enough fiber, complex carbs, and calcium. “I would do a mix of animal proteins and plant proteins,” King says.

I narrowly avoided gout, but the experience served as a reminder that protein has limits. For anyone chasing fitness goals, the takeaway is clear: moderate your intake, drink plenty of water, and balance animal proteins with plant sources. As King puts it, most people are being sold more protein than they actually need. Sometimes, the healthiest choice is knowing when to stop.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *