The Classic Cosmopolitan: A Tart, Citrusy Cocktail With a Colorful History

The cosmopolitan is a cocktail with many shades: a pop culture icon, a bartender’s favorite, and a drink that has earned its place on menus everywhere. It is tart, citrusy, and just sweet enough, with a signature pink hue courtesy of a splash of cranberry juice. Think of it as a cranberry margarita, but with vodka in place of tequila, plus fresh lime juice and a dash of orange liqueur. Shaken together, these elements produce a bright and refreshing drink that works just as well at a casual get together as it does at a sophisticated bar.

The most important decision you’ll make when mixing a cosmopolitan involves the cranberry juice. Look for a bottle labeled “cranberry juice cocktail,” a sweetened cranberry drink that balances the fresh lime and orange liqueur. Pure 100% cranberry juice is considerably more tart; if that’s what you have, there’s a simple substitution.

Cranberry juice cocktail is a sweetened cranberry drink, commonly sold by brands like Ocean Spray. It differs from bottles labeled “100% cranberry juice,” which are more tart and have a concentrated, tannic quality. The cocktail provides enough sweetness to balance the lime and orange liqueur while giving the drink its familiar bright pink color.

If you accidentally bought 100% cranberry juice, use 3/4 oz pure unsweetened cranberry juice plus 1/2 teaspoon simple syrup in place of the 1 oz cranberry juice cocktail.

When it comes to orange liqueur, Cointreau and triple sec are often used interchangeably at the bar, and for good reason: Cointreau is a type of triple sec. Cointreau has a bright, floral orange flavor that works particularly well with cranberry and lime, but any good quality triple sec makes an easy substitute. Other options exist too. Dry curaçao will yield a slightly less sweet drink with a hint of baking spice, think clove or nutmeg, perhaps giving a Thanksgiving twist to the standard cosmo. Grand Marnier brings a deeper, warmer flavor and makes the drink slightly heavier. Either can be swapped in at a 1:1 ratio.

A good quality plain vodka works well, but citrus vodka is also traditional. Bartender Toby Cecchini’s influential version of the cosmopolitan, served at New York’s Odeon in the late 1980s, used Absolut Citron.

The cosmopolitan has a history that goes beyond its Sex and the City fame. When the HBO series started airing in the late 1990s, it turned the drink into an international phenomenon, but the cocktail had made several rounds before Carrie Bradshaw ever ordered one. Versions circulated in the queer communities of Provincetown and San Francisco for years before Cecchini helped establish the modern cosmo at Odeon. As he told former BA editor Priya Krishna in an oral history of the drink, a colleague’s friends introduced him to a version made with well vodka, lime syrup, and grenadine. “It was gross, but it looked pretty,” Cecchini recalled. He reworked it with newly on the market Absolut Citron, Cointreau, fresh lime juice, and cranberry juice. The drink caught on with the Odeon’s staff, celebrity clientele like Madonna and Sandra Bernhard, and the downtown Manhattan crowd.

So, isn’t a cosmopolitan just a vodka cranberry? Not quite. Sure, both drinks contain vodka and cranberry juice, but that’s where the similarities end. A cosmopolitan adds fresh lime juice and orange liqueur, giving it that distinctive tart, citrusy flavor. It’s also a shaken cocktail, which provides some dilution and slightly aerates the drink for balance. A vodka cranberry is a standard highball, typically built in the glass from which it’s sipped.

To make the classic version, combine 2 oz vodka, 1 oz cranberry juice cocktail, 3/4 oz fresh lime juice, and 3/4 oz triple sec in a cocktail shaker. Fill the shaker with ice, cover, and shake vigorously until the outside of the shaker is very cold, about 20 seconds. Strain the cocktail through a Hawthorne strainer or a slotted spoon into a martini glass. Garnish with an orange twist.

This recipe was first printed in Bon Appetit’s May 2016 issue, and has been updated for style. Whether you’re revisiting an old favorite or trying it for the first time, the cosmopolitan remains a bright, refreshing cocktail with a story as layered as its flavor.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *