The S&P 500 has delivered spectacular returns over the past decade, but its heavy reliance on a handful of technology giants has experts warning that investors may be taking on more risk than they realize.
Low cost S&P 500 index funds have long served as the backbone of many investment portfolios. The 90/10 allocation to the index and short term Treasuries, famously endorsed by Warren Buffett, has been pitched as all that long term investors truly need.
The index, which represents roughly 80% of the total U.S. market capitalization, has been a standout performer, more than quadrupling in value over the past decade. Yet its heavy tilt toward information technology has created lingering concentration risks. Those risks have grown so pronounced that some investors see echoes of the dot com crash of 2000 to 2002, when the S&P 500 lost nearly half of its value.
“This S&P 500 isn’t your father’s index,” said Mitch Goldberg, president of ClientFirst Strategy. “It’s super-powered by the information technology sector, which makes up about 37% of total value. Adding in the communications sector, which includes companies like Meta and Netflix, brings it to almost 50%.”
That concentration is especially concerning for those nearing retirement, who may rely on their portfolios to generate income in the years ahead.
Goldberg noted that the five smallest sectors in the stock market, consumer staples, energy, utilities, real estate and materials, account for just 14% of the S&P 500. He recommends investors consider an equal weight S&P 500 index to broaden their exposure, and also add fixed income, international equity and small cap domestic equity.
“Diversification helps you avoid becoming dependent on yesterday’s winners, which is a form of recency bias,” he said. “Adding non-correlated investments can improve your overall portfolio, and is important in a bear market, when you don’t want all your investments to move in tandem.”
Overexposure to the S&P 500 also carries opportunity risk. “If your exposure in the S&P 500 is too high, you’re missing out,” said Todd Rosenbluth, head of research and editorial at TMX VettaFi. He pointed to small cap and international equity funds that have outperformed this year, including the iShares Core S&P Small Cap ETF (IJR) and the iShares Core MSCI Emerging Markets ETF (IEMG).
Investors can also find better valuations outside the S&P 500, according to Ankur Patel, chief investment officer of Ellevest. “The S&P trades around 20 times forward earnings while developed international and emerging markets sit closer to 10-15x. You’re paying a lot less for each dollar of earnings overseas.”
Neena Mishra, director of ETF research at Zacks Investment Research, said investors can reduce volatility with other value oriented investments. She suggests holding dividend growth ETFs such as the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD), which focuses on the quality and sustainability of dividends. “Health care, consumer staples, and energy receive the largest allocations in the portfolio, helping investors diversify away from the mega cap tech giants. It has also significantly outperformed the S&P 500 Index this year,” she said.
In fixed income, Mishra prefers shorter term government bonds over corporate, high yield and long term government options. “Many investors are still scarred by 2022, when both stocks and bonds nosedived as inflation surged,” she said. Given persistently elevated inflation and interest rate volatility, longer duration bond ETFs are inherently riskier. Ultra short Treasury bill ETFs such as the iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF (SGOV) and the Vanguard 0-3 Month Treasury Bill ETF (VBIL) have become popular with investors. “These cash-like instruments offer low risk along with a decent level of income,” she said.
Mishra also argues that gold has a role in a diversified portfolio. “I believe gold deserves a place in any diversified portfolio because of its low correlation with traditional asset classes,” she said. She noted that the SPDR Gold MiniShares Trust (GLDM) and the iShares Gold Trust Micro (IAUM) are low cost options for long term investors.
Patel advises investors to think about their time horizon when evaluating S&P 500 exposure. “Here’s one way to think about it: if the S&P 500 fell 20% tomorrow, would it change your plans? If the answer is yes, you’re overexposed.”
He added that the decision comes down to goals, not age. “Think about it less in terms of age and more in terms of when you actually need the money. Money you won’t touch for 10-plus years can be more aggressively allocated. Money you need in the next few years shouldn’t depend on what Nvidia reports next quarter. Buffett’s 90/10 rule is fine if you have a few decades and the tolerance for it, but not if you need a down payment on a house in, say, a few years.”
The rapid rise of artificial intelligence holdings also affects the risk profile of S&P 500 heavy portfolios. “The information technology and communication services sectors together make up almost half of the portfolio and are dominated by AI-related names,” Mishra said. “Portfolio diversification is often called the only ‘free lunch’ in investing because combining uncorrelated assets can reduce portfolio volatility without necessarily sacrificing expected returns.”
None of this diminishes the role the S&P 500 has played in building wealth. Goldberg noted that index funds have been a powerful tool for retirement savers since the advent of the 401(k). “But now I can’t help but feel that people have heard that story for so long that they think it’s a risk-less investment,” he said.
A low cost S&P 500 index ETF remains a solid foundation for long term growth. But adding uncorrelated assets can help investors lower volatility and avoid depending on yesterday’s winners.