‘Sterling Point’ Is A Refreshing YA Hit: Our Spoiler-Filled Review

Megan Park has built a devoted following with films like The Fallout and My Old Ass, and her latest project, Sterling Point, brings her signature touch to television. The Prime Video series stands out in a crowded young adult landscape because it is an original story, not an adaptation with a built in fanbase. Here, entertainment writers Rachel Choy and Simran Pasricha break down what makes the show work, from its natural dialogue to its central sapphic romance, and debate whether it deserves a second season. Spoilers ahead.

Sterling Point follows 17-year-old Annie Jacobson (Ella Rubin) and her adopted twin brother Connor (Keen Ruffalo), who learn that their estranged grandfather has died and left them a cottage in Muskoka. After discovering their father Steven (Jay Duplass) has been hiding secrets, Annie heads to Canada to uncover the truth. Along the way, she finds a group of lake kids who become friends, confidantes, and romantic interests. But the show’s most important relationship is between Annie and her surprise sister Ramona (Amélie Hoeferle), as the two navigate a new sibling bond while dealing with a family history of lies.

For Pasricha, the show felt immediate and authentic. “I loved how real it felt,” she said. “It didn’t feel like I was watching a show about Gen Zs. I felt like it was speaking my language, it had similar vernacular.” She pointed to the Camp Rock references and the actors’ ability to ad lib as key to that authenticity. Choy agreed, noting that the freedom of an original IP allowed the writers to capture a genuine Gen Z voice, unlike adaptations that are tied to source material.

The conversation turned to the marketing, which hinted at a love triangle, but Choy said the show subverted expectations. “It had a gay boyfriend, which was hilarious,” she said. “And then suddenly had feelings for the first time for like an actual potential partner.” Pasricha appreciated that both male love interests felt like good choices, and that Annie’s sexual debut with Rory, not Ellis, felt natural. “Sometimes you just lose it on a whim,” she said.

The writers also praised the series for its portrayal of the relationship between Oona and Ramona. “It felt really natural and normal,” Pasricha said. “We don’t get a lot of lesbian romance arcs in media whatsoever.” She noted the online reaction has been positive, though some have asked why Oona couldn’t be bisexual. Choy speculated that some writers default to bisexuality to make audiences more comfortable, which Pasricha called “a really f**ked up position.”

Not everything was perfect. Both writers noted the characters’ wealth felt like a fantasy. “Ultimately, Annie is this rich girl coming to this lake area,” Pasricha said. “Nobody is really struggling, everyone has a boat.” But she admitted that escapism is part of the appeal. They also questioned the ages of the characters, with 17-year-olds traveling solo and making rash decisions, though Pasricha said that rashness felt true to life.

The show leaves room for more story. “They’ve set it up for the story to continue,” Choy said. “It’s not a huge cliffhanger, but it makes you want to know what’s going to happen.” Pasricha was effusive in her praise: “I think Megan Park is a genius director, creator, and writer.” Both agreed the series is worth watching, and issued a playful threat if it doesn’t get a second season. “I really hope so, or I’ll be really upset,” Pasricha said. “This is a threat.”

Sterling Point is a standout YA series that benefits from original storytelling, authentic dialogue, and a focus on meaningful relationships over melodrama. With strong performances and a setup ripe for continuation, it’s a show worth watching now and rooting for in the future.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *