How American Brands Lost Their Edge in China

 

China was once a magnet for American consumer brands, drawing in companies with a population of more than 1.4 billion and the promise of explosive growth. But that promise has faded for many U.S. names. Rising geopolitical tensions, a surge in domestic competition, and a widening disconnect from Chinese shoppers have left once dominant brands like Nike, Starbucks and General Motors scrambling.

Aaron Cheris, head of global retail practice at Bain & Company, told CNBC that China’s scale has long made it irresistible. “China is such a big market. The numbers are so big so quickly when you talk about China that sort of everybody has wanted to try, and that’s why all brands went there,” he said. Yet companies have not adjusted to the local market and its changing structures and needs, he said. “If anything, the question isn’t what’s going wrong in China, it’s why isn’t that happening in the rest of the world,” Cheris added.

Cheris argued that American products often carry a price premium that Chinese consumers no longer see as worthwhile, while domestic brands benefit from faster innovation cycles and stronger distribution networks. “We’re just not nearly as developed. Our brands don’t necessarily think and develop quite in the same way,” he said.

The backdrop includes years of U.S.-China geopolitical friction, including President Donald Trump’s volatile tariff agenda. That has coincided with a rise in Chinese pride and a preference for buying local. Some domestic brands have prompted industry-wide disruption, accelerating innovation and triggering price wars.

Retailers on the Ropes

Nike, a longstanding fixture in the Chinese market, has watched its business shrink 30% since 2021. Annual revenue in the country hit its lowest level in eight years this spring. The company, which previously counted China as its fastest-growing region, is overhauling its distribution model as shoppers shift to domestic sportswear labels. Yaling Jiang, founder of research firm ApertureChina, told CNBC that Nike has “just become irrelevant” in China, while Adidas has gained traction.

That decline comes despite a broader Chinese sports renaissance. The country’s sportswear market has more than doubled over the past decade, according to GlobalData. Nike’s own management is cautious about a rebound. Outgoing CFO Matt Friend said on a June earnings call that he could not determine when the China business would return to growth. Cathy Sparks, vice president and general manager for Greater China, has said the company is actively working to reconnect with Chinese consumers.

Estée Lauder faces similar headwinds. CEO Stéphane de La Faverie said on a conference call in early June that he does not expect China to resume double digit growth anytime soon. “We deal by making sure that our brands are the most locally relevant in the market where we operate,” he said, adding that he is confident performance will recover. On a call Wednesday, de La Faverie reported net sales growth in mainland China, saying “the market is strong.”

Gap, after years of struggling to connect with Chinese shoppers, sold its China business to e-commerce firm Baozun in 2022 for $40 million in cash. Baozun refined Gap’s local strategy, and the retailer broke even for the first time earlier this year. It now plans to open 50 new stores in mainland China in 2026. Abercrombie & Fitch is reportedly seeking a similar local partner to take over its operations.

Not all Western retailers are fading. Lululemon expects its China business to grow about 20% this year, and Ralph Lauren posted 40% growth in its most recent quarter. Cheris attributes the difference to what he calls “the basics” of strategy. “Am I coming in with a good value? Did I have a compelling product that felt locally relevant? Am I advertising and making it available in the channels and stores that are winning in that market?” he said. “It really is a blocking and tackling and running your brand right kind of story.”

A Bitter Brew for Starbucks

In food and beverage, Kentucky Fried Chicken continues to thrive, but Starbucks has seen a stark reversal. The coffee chain entered mainland China in 1999 and by 2015 it was the company’s second largest market. The Covid-19 pandemic triggered a downward turn as Chinese consumers gravitated to cheaper local coffee brands. Laxman Narasimhan, who was CEO at the time, said on an earnings call in early 2024: “The market is going through a transition as we see an increase in mass market competitors, which we believe will shake out over time, and the market will emerge looking fundamentally different than what we see today.”

Luckin Coffee now operates more than three times as many stores in China as Starbucks and offers drinks at steep discounts. With its U.S. business also under pressure, Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol turned to Boyu Capital, forming a joint venture to run China operations. Boyu owns about 60% of the venture and intends to use its local expertise to revive sales.

Consumer Goods Struggle

Procter & Gamble, which counts China as its second largest market, has seen product sales struggle. CEO Shailesh Jejurikar told analysts in late July: “Coming out of Covid, [Greater China] was a depressed market. It was a tough competitive environment, and the results were not great.” The premium skincare line SK-II, which P&G owns, has seen sales seesaw. Reduced travel and cautious spending among Chinese consumers have hurt the brand, which relies heavily on luxury travel retail and duty-free stores. In late 2023, anti-Japanese sentiment also weighed on demand, given SK-II’s Japanese origin.

Jejurikar insisted many P&G brands remain strong, arguing that some categories are hurt more by the consumer environment than by a loss of brand equity. He highlighted diapers made with silk fibers as a product winning over shoppers. “We are now growing share in China for the first time in 15 quarters, driven by fundamental changes we made similar to what we’re doing in the company,” he said.

Detroit’s China Problem

The U.S. auto industry’s decline in China has been dramatic. A decade ago, the country was the biggest potential growth market for automakers. Now it is a massive restructuring zone, with domestic car companies on the rise and overcapacity fueling a price war. S&P Global Mobility estimates that GM, Ford and Stellantis, the Detroit Big Three, collectively held a 21.4% global market share in 2019, but that will fall to about 15.7% in 2025.

General Motors, the longest standing U.S. automaker in China, earned roughly $2 billion annually in the region in 2018. Since then, it has posted two consecutive years of losses in 2024 and 2025. Domestic manufacturers, powered by government support and a culture of innovation and speed, have reshaped the market. A slowing Chinese market and underutilized plants have also pushed local companies like BYD and Geely to export aggressively to Europe, Canada and South America.

Chinese consumers are increasingly choosing electric vehicles for their price and quality. New energy vehicles, which include battery and hybrid models, accounted for 65.1% of new passenger cars sold in July, up from 54% a year earlier, according to data released Tuesday by the China Passenger Car Association. Tesla, the EV leader, is reportedly considering selling or spinning off its Chinese business, according to a July report in The Wall Street Journal. Ford, which has taken steps to position itself as the most American automaker, will shift production of its Lincoln models from China to the U.S. beginning in 2030. Ford’s China sales fell 32.4% between 2018 and 2022, and it no longer reports regional financial results.

Cheris said turning around a China business requires more than exporting a global playbook. The key, he said, is for brands to build genuine local capabilities. “The key will be which brands take it seriously enough and really build enough local capability to do that, rather than just saying, ‘I’m going to take what I built globally and try to sell it to a Chinese consumer,'” he said. CNBC’s Gabrielle Fonrouge, Amelia Lucas and Mike Wayland contributed to this report.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *